Timeless homes deserve thoughtful updates that honor their original design. Replacing the siding on a historic property involves more than just choosing a new material. It requires careful planning, attention to detail, and a clear understanding of local preservation rules. In this guide, we’ll walk you through the key considerations for siding replacement for historic homes, including material options, design limitations, and how to maintain both beauty and structural integrity.
Why Siding Replacement for Historic Homes is Different
Historic homes are a treasure, but their age and unique designs can make exterior upgrades more complex. Here are some key challenges homeowners face:
1. High Costs
Replacing siding on historic homes is undeniably expensive. Many of the materials originally used are no longer mass-produced, and matching those aesthetics often requires custom solutions. For example, certain scalloped shingle styles that were once available from manufacturers like James Hardie are now discontinued due to low demand.
2. Limited Design Choices
In neighborhoods such as Curtis Park or areas under historic preservation regulations, homeowners must adhere to strict guidelines. These rules ensure that any updates align with the original architectural style, but they can also limit your material and design options.
3. Durability Concerns
If your home was built to mimic historic designs but doesn’t use long-lasting materials, you may find the current siding rotting or falling apart. This can make replacement both necessary and urgent.
Choosing the Right Materials for Historic Homes
The key to successful siding replacement for historic homes is selecting materials that balance aesthetics, durability, and cost. Here are some recommendations based on our experience:
1. High-Quality Cedar Siding
For homeowners committed to maintaining the original look, high-quality cedar siding is an excellent choice. While this option comes with a higher price tag, it provides an authentic appearance that blends seamlessly with historic designs. Cedar siding must be properly sealed and painted with multiple coats to ensure longevity.
2. James Hardie Fiber Cement
If you’re open to modern alternatives, James Hardie fiber cement siding offers an excellent balance of durability and design flexibility. This material can mimic the appearance of wood while providing far greater resistance to weather and wear.
3. Innovative Custom Products
In some cases, custom solutions may be the only way to match specific architectural details. Although this approach can be costly, it ensures your home retains its historic charm.
Additional Considerations: Windows and Energy Efficiency
When working on historic homes, siding replacement is often paired with other updates, such as window replacements. Older windows in historic homes are notorious for their low energy efficiency, which can lead to significant heat loss and higher utility bills.
Our Recommendation for Window Replacement
We recommend Pella Reserve windows, which are customizable and offer a wood exterior that blends perfectly with historic aesthetics. These windows not only enhance your home’s energy efficiency but also preserve its timeless look.
Steps to Approach Siding Replacement
To simplify the process, we’ve outlined a step-by-step guide to replacing siding on a historic home:
- Consult Historic Society Guidelines: Before starting, confirm any restrictions or design requirements from local historic societies or preservation boards.
- Evaluate the Existing Siding: Determine whether the current siding can be repaired or if a full replacement is necessary.
- Choose Appropriate Materials: Decide whether to go with authentic wood siding, modern fiber cement, or a custom solution.
- Budget for the Project: Be prepared for higher costs associated with materials, custom work, and labor.
- Hire an Experienced Contractor: Work with a team like Bellwether that specializes in siding replacement for historic homes. We understand the complexities of these projects and can guide you every step of the way.
In Summary
Siding replacement for historic homes is a significant investment, but it’s also an opportunity to enhance your home’s beauty and protect its structure for years to come. Whether you’re preserving a classic design or opting for more durable materials, our team at Bellwether has the experience and expertise to help you achieve your goals.
If you’re considering siding replacement, contact us today to discuss your project. We’ll help you address the challenges of working on a historic home and ensure your property looks stunning while staying true to its roots.
